Pete Hill, a standout in the Negro leagues but now nearly forgotten, boasts a Hall of Fame accolade but lacks a headstone to commemorate his legacy. “Is This Heaven?” is a poignant documentary that dives into Hill’s life and career, illuminating tales of struggle, injustice, and unparalleled talent.

The film doesn’t stop at recounting his achievements; it probes the unsettling mystery of a potentially disturbed grave at Burr Oak Cemetery. Historians are captured on their quest to locate his true resting place. As they dig deeper, they uncover discrepancies on Hill’s National Baseball Hall of Fame plaque, sparking an endeavor to correct the annals of history.