| 2022, Dec. 3 | Snow Ballers 6, Wicked Wrappers | 56° | Sergeant Neil Anderson |
| 2021, Dec. 4 | Sugar Cookies 8, Snickerdoodles 2 | 39° | Sergeant Jonathan Hansen |
| 2020, Dec. 12 | Santa's Stompers 8, Roaring Chestnuts 5 | 41° | Sergeant William Neill |
| 2019, Dec. 7 | Silent Knights 13, Gangsta Wrappers 8 | 23° | Lance Corporal Max Marchino |
| 2018, Dec. 1 | Balls of Holly 6, Tinsel Toes 5 | 50° | Sgt. Tyler Longe McCann and SSgt. Zachary Pineau |
| 2017, Dec. 2 | Stocking Stuffers 12, Santa's Helpers 2 | 39° | Master Gunnery Sgt. Bill McCorkle |
| 2016, Dec. 3 | Gingerbread Men vs. Toy Soldiers | 37° | Master Gunnery Sgt. Bill McCorkle & Sgt. Tyler Longe McCann |
| 2015, Dec. 5 | Nice 3, Naughty 1 | 52° | Master Gunnery Sgt. Bill McCorkle |
| 2014, Dec. 6 | Calling Birds 18, Drumming Drummers 17 | 41° | Master Gunnery Sgt. Bill McCorkle |
| 2013, Dec. 7 | French Hens 7, Turtle Doves 5 | 37° | Master Gunnery Sgt. Bill McCorkle |
| 2012, Dec. 1 | Baystate Blizzard 8, Atlantic Frost 5 | 28° | The Rivier University Baseball Team |
| 2011, Dec. 3 | Young Bucks 6, Aging Stallions 5 | 39° | Sgt. Major Rick Peterson |
| 2010, Dec. 4 | Snowmen 10, Snowflakes 8 | 41° | Sergeant Jonathan Chan |
| 2009, Dec. 5 | Team Rudolph 8, Team Santa 6 | 42° | BFD Fire Lieutenant Patrick Slattery |
| 2008, Dec. 13 | MABL 5, MSBL 3 | 28° | USMC |
| 2007, Dec. 8 | MABL 7, MABL 3 | 37° | BPD & MABL Player/U.S. Marine, Tim Fish |
| 2006, Dec. 2 | MABL 5, MSBL 1 (Game 1)
MABL 4, MSBL 4 (Game 2) | 47° | USMC & BPD Captain Kelley McCormick |
| 2005, Dec. 3 | MSBL 6, MABL 3 | 35° | U.S. Marines Jack McDonald & Paul Nolan, & MABL Player/U.S. Marine, Tim Fish |
| 2004, Dec. 4 | MABL 7, MSBL 3 | 40° | U.S. Marines Jack McDonald & Paul Nolan |
| 2003, Dec. 6 | Canceled due to 3 feet of snow! | 28° | - |
| 2002, Dec. 1 | MABL 6, MSBL 3 | 31° | - |
| 2001, Dec. 2 | MSBL 17, MABL 7 (Game 1)
MABL 6, MSBL 2 (Game 2) | 48° | - |
