In “The Broken Hearts Club,” a circle of gay friends in West Hollywood bond over softball and work at a local restaurant. They lean on each other as they navigate love, loss, and identity crises. Key characters include Dennis, the group’s anchor, Cole, a habitual heartbreaker, and Benji, the youngest member finding his way.

Their friendships are tested when a new member, Kevin, joins their softball team and a tragedy occurs. Despite life’s curveballs, the team finds strength in their close-knit community, highlighting the universal importance of friendship and acceptance.