In Romance in the Outfield: Double Play, Tyler returns from an injury that could end his career and coaches softball, against Kenzie – a pretty girls whom he has a history with. Tyler must choose what’s most important between a career and love, and Kenzie must let go and give him a second chance. Will Tyler choose his baseball career over her? And will she steal his heart, or strike out in the game of love?

The baseball movie is a sequel to Pitching Love & Catching Faith.