As the coach of a struggling baseball team at a local Christian high school, Police Sergeant James Buanacore is far from the life he once knew. A disastrous turn in a drug operation had compelled him to leave his cherished profession as a cop. Now, facing a crisis of faith and teaching Criminal Justice to at-risk youths, James finds himself at a crossroads.

Just when he contemplates walking away from it all, an inquisitive student challenges him. This prompts James to embark on a profound investigation into the very existence of Jesus Christ, a journey that promises transformative revelations for everyone involved.